<%@LANGUAGE="JAVASCRIPT" CODEPAGE="1252"%> Process
   


©Glynis Steward

Did the punishment fit the crime?

 

 

 

 

Home

Introduction

The Task

The Process

...Timeline

Resources

Presentation

Evaluation

Webquest created by Dianne Ruffles with Josie Belvedere

Created June 2004

Updated August 2008

 

Process - Click HERE for Timeline

A. Group activity
You will be assigned to a group of 4 students. Each group will select one of the time periods / cultural groupings and look at crime and punishment within the chosen time period. Each group will be asked to consider if the punishments in their chosen time period reflected the values in that society and prepare a group presentation for the class.

Individual Roles
In your group explore justice in your time period by taking on one of the following roles. Questions this big and important are best answered when a few people are working on it at one time. Things work even better when you decide to look at the question from different perspectives. This way team members become experts on different aspects of the question and then come together to share their learning.

  • The accused
  • Prosecuting Authority
  • The Advocate for the Defence
  • Judge/Magistrate

The Time periods / Cultural groupings are:
1. Babylonian and Egyptian times
2. Ancient Greek and Roman times
3. Early Middle Ages - 1200-1450
4. Elizabethan Era - 1450-1750
5. Industrial times – 1750-1900
6. Ancient India and China
7. Aboriginal Tribal Law

To assist your group develop their perspective, it may be useful to develop an understanding of life from a range of viewpoints during the chosen time period. Use the resources indicated to develop your group and individual response.

Explore life at the time from different perspectives – as a noble, peasant, magistrate, member of the clergy, as a law enforcement officer. Did the age and sex of the offender make a difference to their treatment by the law of the time?

Questions for the GROUP to address in their presentation

1. Describe the values and morals of the society you are researching (this can include customs and beliefs at that time).

2. Who made the laws in that society?

3. What were the legal procedures?

4. Did crimes, as offences against society as a whole, exist in this society? Explain the types of crimes and punishments for such crimes.

5. Was the law (legal system) fair? Explain.

6. Was the law effective? Justify your answer

Useful resources and links

B. Individual activity - Choose one of the following or negotiate an activity with Ms Belvedere:
1. Create a Virtual museum web page to illustrate “justice” in your chosen time period, include relevant images to demonstrate your points
2. Create an artefact from the period / cultural grouping for an exhibition at the museum on the history of punishment

Answer the following questions:

  • What is the purpose of the artefact?
  • When and how was it used?
  • How long was it used for?
  • Who was punished with this artefact? (i.e. did the punishment apply equally, without discrimination?)
  • What was the process used when administering this sanction? (e.g. trial)

3. You are a reporter - produce a front page of the newspaper reporting on a crime and the punishment meted out

In your article, address the following questions:

  • Outline the facts of the case
  • Describe the legal procedures followed in this case
  • Outline the role of legal personnel involved in the case
  • Outline the sanction applied
  • As an investigative reporter do you believe the outcome was fair and just? Justify your response.